Transformer Failures: Financial Losses Analysis and Prevention Strategies

Transformer failures: the insulation is the predominant cause of failure.

Introduction

Transformers are vital components of the electrical grid, ensuring the efficient transmission and distribution of electricity by stepping up or stepping down voltage levels. However, their failures can lead to significant financial losses, disrupt power supply, and challenge grid reliability. This article draws on a comprehensive study by the International Association of Engineering Insurers (IMIA) from 1997 to 2001 to explore the extent of transformer failure losses and propose actionable strategies to mitigate them.

Scale of Transformer Losses

Over the five-year period from 1997 to 2001, the IMIA study documented 94 transformer failures, resulting in a staggering total loss of $286,628,811. These losses encompass both property damage and business interruption costs, reflecting the broad economic impact of such incidents.

Year	Total # of Losses	Total Loss	Total Property Damage	Total Business Interruption
1997	19	$40,779,507	$25,036,673	$15,742,834
1998	25	$24,932,235	$24,897,114	$35,121
1999	15	$37,391,591	$36,994,202	$397,389
2000	20	$150,181,779	$56,858,084	$93,323,695
2001	15	$33,343,700	$19,453,016	$13,890,684
Grand Total	94	$286,628,811	$163,239,089	$123,389,722

• Cost Metrics: For the 78 cases with transformer size data, the average property damage cost was approximately $9,000 per MVA (megavolt-ampere) or $9 per kVA (kilovolt-ampere), underscoring the high cost associated with larger transformers.

• The year 2000 stands out due to an extraordinary business interruption loss at a power plant, over $86 million USD, highlighting how a single event can skew annual figures and emphasizing the need for robust risk management.

Losses by Application

Transformer failures vary by their application, with the study categorizing them into Generator Step Up (GSU), Industrial, Utility Substations, and unknown:

• Generator Step Up (GSU): 36 failures, $203,533,199—the highest total loss, even without the $86 million claim, due to their large size and critical role in power generation.

• Utility Substations: 38 failures, $19,797,476—the highest number of incidents, though less costly overall.

• Industrial: 18 failures, $55,881,762—notable for significant losses, including four claims in 1999 totaling nearly $25 million.

• Unknown: 2 failures, $7,416,375.

GSU transformers’ high loss amounts reflect their exposure to substantial operational stresses and the cascading effects of their failure in power plants.

Causes of Transformer Failures

The study identified insulation failure as the predominant cause, with other factors contributing to the failure profile:

• Insulation Failure: 24 cases, $149,967,277—caused by heat, oxidation, acidity, and moisture degrading insulation over time.

• Design/Material/Workmanship: 22 cases, $64,696,051—issues like poor brazing or inadequate core insulation.

• Other Causes: Included oil contamination (4 cases), overloading (5), fire/explosion (3), line surge (4), improper maintenance/operation (5), flood (2), loose connections (6), lightning (3), and moisture (1).

Insulation failure’s dominance suggests that aging and environmental stressors are critical risk factors, while design flaws indicate areas for improvement in manufacturing standards.

The Role of Aging

The average age of transformers at failure was 18 years, with many units installed post-World War II now exceeding their expected lifespan. The study predicts an increase in failures as the global transformer fleet ages, based on a failure rate model adapted from actuarial mortality curves (e.g., Perks’ formula). This aging infrastructure, combined with increased loads, heightens vulnerability to mechanical and dielectric failures.

Strategies to Prevent Transformer Losses

To reduce the frequency and severity of transformer failures, the following strategies are recommended based on the study’s insights:

1. Regular Maintenance and Inspection

   • Conduct routine oil testing, thermal imaging, and electrical diagnostics to detect insulation degradation or loose connections early.

   • Address incipient issues before they escalate into failures.

2. Condition Monitoring

   • Employ technologies like dissolved gas analysis (DGA) to monitor transformer health and provide early warnings of potential faults.

3. Load Management

   • Prevent overloading by monitoring and redistributing loads or upgrading transformers to match demand, extending their operational life.

4. Surge Protection

   • Install surge arresters and ensure proper grounding to mitigate damage from line surges and lightning strikes.

5. Quality in Design and Procurement

   • Prioritize reliability over initial cost when purchasing transformers, selecting manufacturers with proven quality standards to minimize design-related failures.

6. Life Cycle Management

   • Implement a program to assess transformer condition, prioritize refurbishments or replacements, and plan for fleet renewal, avoiding premature or unnecessary retirements.

7. Emergency Preparedness

   • Maintain spare transformers or secure rapid replacement agreements to minimize business interruption losses following a failure.

Conclusion

Transformer failures, as evidenced by the $286.6 million in losses over five years, pose a significant challenge to the electrical grid’s reliability and economic stability. By understanding the primary causes—led by insulation failure—and the impact of aging, stakeholders can adopt proactive strategies to mitigate risks. Regular maintenance, advanced monitoring, and strategic planning are key to ensuring transformers remain reliable, safeguarding both infrastructure and the communities they serve.

---

Our Solutions

HV Assets has a complete solution for monitoring water in transformers using an advanced water, hydrogen, temperature and pressure sensor, the Basic Care Sensor, and the Early Warning Sensor, measuring hydrogen and temperature. In addition, it has a flexible IoT connection and a data analysis and diagnostic platform. Click here to check the details.

Basic Care Sensor, measurement of humidity, hydrogen, temperature and pressure.

Early Warning Sensor, measurement of hydrogen and temperature.

---

References

Analysis of Transformer Failures, William H. Bartley P.E., International Association of Engineers Insurers, 36th Annual Conference - Stockolm, 2003.