Condition-Based Maintenance for Transformers: Tools and Implementation

Augusto Moser
Jun 21
5 min read

Updated: Jul 5

In the realm of power systems, transformers are vital yet vulnerable assets. Their reliability is paramount, and their failure can be costly. Traditional maintenance strategies often rely on fixed schedules, but these can be inefficient and may not prevent unexpected failures. Condition-Based Maintenance (CBM) offers a proactive approach by tailoring maintenance actions to the actual condition of the transformer. This article explores CBM, its primary tools, and a practical implementation plan, drawing insights from CIGRE's technical brochures 445, Guide for Transformer Maintenance, and 761, Condition Assessment of Power Transformers.

What is Condition-Based Maintenance for Transformers?

Condition-Based Maintenance is a strategy where maintenance is performed based on the equipment's current condition rather than a predetermined schedule. By monitoring and assessing the transformer's health, CBM aims to intervene only when necessary, optimizing maintenance efforts and costs while enhancing reliability. Unlike Time-Based Maintenance (TBM), which occurs at fixed intervals regardless of condition, CBM uses real-time data to determine when action is required, reducing unnecessary interventions and focusing resources where they are most needed.

Main Tools for CBM in Transformers

CBM relies on condition monitoring techniques to assess transformer health. The following are the primary tools highlighted in the CIGRE brochures:

Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA)
DGA is a cornerstone of CBM, analyzing gases dissolved in the transformer's insulating oil to detect incipient faults such as overheating, arcing, or partial discharges. Standards like IEC 60599 and IEEE C57.104 guide interpretation, making DGA a widely recognized diagnostic tool for early fault detection.
Oil Tests
Beyond DGA, oil tests assess properties like moisture content, acidity, and dielectric strength. These tests provide insights into the oil’s condition and, indirectly, the transformer's overall health, as degradation in oil can accelerate insulation wear.
Electrical Tests
Tests such as insulation resistance, power factor (or dissipation factor), and winding resistance measurements evaluate the dielectric and electrical integrity of the transformer. These are typically performed offline but are critical for identifying insulation degradation.
Thermal Monitoring
Techniques like infrared scanning detect abnormal heating or hot spots, indicating issues such as poor connections or cooling system inefficiencies. This non-invasive method is valuable for in-service assessments.
Visual Inspections
Regular physical checks identify visible signs of deterioration, such as oil leaks, corrosion, or damaged components. While subjective, these inspections complement more technical diagnostics.
On-Line Monitoring Systems
Continuous monitoring using intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) tracks parameters like gas levels, moisture, and temperature in real time. These systems provide early warnings of deterioration, enabling timely interventions and reducing the risk of catastrophic failure.

Our Solutions

HV Assets has a complete solution for monitoring transformers using an advanced water, hydrogen, temperature and pressure sensor, the Basic Care Sensor, and the Early Warning Sensor, measuring hydrogen and temperature. Click here to check the technical data.

Basic Sensor, water and hydrogen sensor — **Basic Care Sensor**

Early Warning, measurement of hydrogen and temperature. — **Early Warning Sensor**

Transformer Assessment Indices (TAIs)

A key aspect of CBM is consolidating condition data into actionable insights. Transformer Assessment Indices (TAIs), as detailed in brochure 761, assign scores to transformers based on condition data, ranking them to prioritize maintenance. TAIs can be tailored to specific goals (e.g., replacement or refurbishment) and use scoring matrices to ensure consistent evaluation of failure modes—like thermal, dielectric, or mechanical degradation—across a fleet.

Practical Implementation Plan for CBM

Implementing CBM for transformers involves a structured, step-by-step approach. Below is a practical plan based on the guidance from the CIGRE brochures:

Understand Your Transformer Fleet
- Action: Create an inventory of all transformers, documenting specifications (e.g., type, rating, age), service history, and operational conditions.
- Purpose: Provides a baseline for assessing condition and planning maintenance.
Identify Critical Transformers
- Action: Assess criticality based on factors like operational importance, safety risks, and failure consequences (e.g., environmental impact or system reliability).
- Purpose: Prioritizes CBM efforts on transformers where failure would have the greatest impact.
Determine Potential Failure Modes
- Action: Identify common failure modes for each transformer type, such as thermal degradation in the active part, dielectric breakdown in bushings, or mechanical wear in tap changers.
- Purpose: Guides the selection of appropriate monitoring tools.
Select Condition Monitoring Techniques
- Action: Choose tools based on failure modes, e.g., DGA for thermal faults, power factor tests for dielectric issues, or Frequency Response Analysis (FRA) for mechanical integrity.
- Purpose: Ensures monitoring aligns with the specific risks of each transformer.
Establish Baselines and Thresholds
- Action: Take initial measurements (e.g., during commissioning or post-maintenance) to establish "normal" conditions, then set thresholds using standards (IEC, IEEE) or manufacturer guidelines.
- Purpose: Defines when a condition warrants action.
Implement a Monitoring Schedule
- Action: Schedule periodic tests (e.g., annual DGA, monthly visual inspections) and install on-line monitoring systems for critical units.
- Purpose: Balances thoroughness with practicality, ensuring timely data collection.
Collect and Manage Data
- Action: Use a Maintenance Management System (MMS) or similar software to store and organize condition data.
- Purpose: Facilitates analysis and trend tracking over time.
Analyze Data and Assess Condition
- Action: Analyze data using trend analysis, diagnostic tools (e.g., Duval triangles for DGA), or TAIs to score and rank transformers.
- Purpose: Translates raw data into a clear picture of transformer health.
Make Maintenance Decisions
- Action: Decide on actions based on assessments—no action for healthy units, minor repairs for small issues, or major refurbishment/replacement for critical conditions.
- Purpose: Targets interventions effectively, optimizing resource use.
Feedback and Improvement
- Action: Review outcomes of maintenance actions and failures (e.g., via post-mortem analysis) to refine monitoring techniques and thresholds.
- Purpose: Enhances the CBM program’s accuracy and effectiveness over time.

Challenges and Considerations

Implementing CBM is not without challenges. Data quality can vary, with missing or outdated information common in large fleets. Expert judgment is often required to interpret complex results, such as DGA patterns. Additionally, investing in on-line monitoring and data management systems can be costly, though justified by the high stakes of transformer failure. CBM is an ongoing process, requiring continuous refinement to adapt to new insights and technologies.

Conclusion

Condition-Based Maintenance enhance transformer management by leveraging real-time condition data to drive maintenance decisions. With tools like DGA, oil tests, and on-line monitoring, and frameworks like TAIs, utilities can enhance reliability, reduce costs, and prioritize interventions effectively. By following a structured implementation plan, asset managers can shift from reactive to proactive maintenance, ensuring robust and efficient power systems for the future.

Our Solutions

The HV Assets Care Platform is a complete solution for data analysis and diagnostics. It includes all the recommended methods from the IEEE standard, including the Duval Triangle and the advanced Combined Duval Pentagon, integrated in an Asset Management dashboard. It provides a Health Index with individual scores to create an asset ranking. For more information, click here.